I’ve held a comprehensive studies of parallels of fashion and you may posts between Baronio’s texts and those we shall now ascribe to Vigano II, to identify this type of website away from 2020-2021 on the completely different of these away from Vigano We, of one’s decades 2018-2019
(Emmanuele Barbieri-Roberto de Mattei) Who’s the actual writer of the newest blogs out of Archbishop Carlo ? Why don’t we make an effort to promote a treatment for practical question we elevated into the Corrispondenza Romana ( here ), beginning with a yes method: the study and you can review of your blog toward texts out-of almost every other writers traceable online. Just what in medical jargon is called stylometric search.
Well, the analysis from lexical and you will stylistic elements leads us to simply you to you’ll be able to creator: “Cesare Baronio,” or “Baronius,” blogger and you can copywriter, out-of 2010 to 2020, of website Opportune Importune.
Preferred to help you Baronio and you may Vigano II is the app so you’re able to progressives of your terminology “counter-church,”, “conciliar sect” ( here that’s where ) otherwise “innovators” ( here this is where ).
Vatican Council II are many times discussed because of the each other as the a keen “idol.” For Baronio, up to “brand new conciliar idol try overthrown, making use of unhappy thoughts of its architects, it would be impractical to penalize the latest high priests who’ve besieged Rome to own fifty many years” (, here ). Vigano II, within his recent Interviews on the Liturgy, in addition to defines Vatican II because a keen idol and you can, instance Baronio, set an excellent Vatican https://besthookupwebsites.org/tr/fabswingers-inceleme/ II-Novus Ordo Missae equivalence.
” Vigano II writes that “the newest architects of the liturgy” was in fact “prelates commonly guessed away from owned by Freemasonry, notoriously modern” ( here ) ; Baronio consequently speaks away from “a good rite composed by the notoriously progressive and you can Masonic prelates” (, right here ).
The instructions of your the brand new liturgy to help you Baronio was “released missals whoever mode is actually that a good plotline to refer in order to getting versions throughout the various federal dialects” (, right here ). Having Vigano II, these types of liturgical instructions “is invented as the an outline, a plotline susceptible to essentially talented stars interested in personal applause” ( right here ).
To own Baronio “this new offertory disappears entirely and come up with way for an excellent Jewish prayer which have an effective pantheistic taste” (, here ); Vigano II talks of it prayer due to the fact “Talmudic offertory” ( here ).
Baronio and Vigano II, when dealing with brand new Novus Ordo out of Paul VI, constantly speak of the new “reformed rite” or “Montinian rite
Predicated on Vigano “the fresh new therefore-called ‘Golden-haired chasuble’ regarding variations one to preceded this new Council, especially in France, has become that kind of poncho and that adopting the Council was passed away from to your you just like the a recovery of one’s modern means,” but is “a historical and additionally liturgical fake” ( right here ). Baronio blogged one: “the brand new conciliar chasuble are an effective horrid poncho who may have nothing to create towards the planeta demonstrated because of the Saint Charles Borromeo (Instructionum fabricae, 1557), hence we find depicted a number of frescoes, drawings, miniatures and you can enamels just like the Middle ages” (, here ).
Vigano denounces “tries to make reformed liturgy respectable which have objectively useless functions off maquillage” ( right here ). Baronio writes that “procedures regarding routine maquillage on Novus Ordo can be found in our have a look at condemned on most instances for the most miserable shipwreck” (, right here ).
One could carry on indefinitely, exactly what things most beyond the spoken coincidences is the same tone, and that conveys an effective smug liturgical, theological, and you will historical degree that Baronio has actually flaunted having a decade into his weblog but is entirely missing on a couple of years off public statements because of the Vigano I.